{ "methodology_version": "2.0.0", "methodology_doc": "docs/methodology-ranking.md", "source_artifact": "data/ranking/leaderboards.json", "generated_by": "scripts/rank.py", "note": "Scores are structural (tier, fit, verified-claim presence, confidence, trust). CE numbers appear only when verified in source org JSON.", "outcomes": [ { "id": "lives_saved", "name": "Lives saved", "cause_ids": [ "cause_global_health_life_saving", "cause_immunization", "cause_malaria", "cause_nutrition", "cause_safe_water" ], "preferred_evaluators": [ "GiveWell" ], "matching_metrics": [ "cost_per_daly", "cost_per_life_saved" ], "org_ids": [ "org_against_malaria_foundation", "org_alima", "org_amf_drc_2027", "org_ansh", "org_development_media_international", "org_dimagi", "org_ea_funds_gh", "org_evidence_action", "org_evidence_action_ifa", "org_evidence_action_ilc", "org_evidence_action_safe_water", "org_evidence_action_syphilis", "org_fortify_health", "org_founders_pledge_gh", "org_gates_malaria", "org_givewell", "org_givewell_all_grants_fund", "org_givewell_top_charities_fund", "org_givewell_unrestricted_fund", "org_global_fund_malaria", "org_gwwc", "org_helen_keller_intl", "org_iodine_global_network", "org_ipa_rtv", "org_jpal_chlorine", "org_living_goods", "org_malaria_consortium", "org_mdgh", "org_new_incentives", "org_new_incentives_ors", "org_nothing_but_nets", "org_nutrition_international", "org_one_acre_fund", "org_path", "org_resolve_to_save_lives", "org_sightsavers", "org_taimaka", "org_uduma", "org_unicef_malaria", "org_unlimit_health", "org_vitamin_angels" ], "org_count": 41 }, { "id": "wellbeing_wellbys", "name": "Wellbeing (WELLBYs)", "cause_ids": [ "cause_cash_transfers", "cause_global_health_wellbeing", "cause_lead_pollution", "cause_mental_health_lmic", "cause_nutrition" ], "preferred_evaluators": [ "Happier Lives Institute" ], "matching_metrics": [ "cost_per_wellby", "multiple_of_cash", "wellbys_per_1000_usd" ], "org_ids": [ "org_actra", "org_alima", "org_evidence_action", "org_evidence_action_ifa", "org_fortify_health", "org_friendship_bench", "org_givedirectly", "org_givewell_all_grants_fund", "org_gwwc", "org_happier_lives_fund", "org_helen_keller_intl", "org_hli", "org_iodine_global_network", "org_nutrition_international", "org_pure_earth", "org_shamiri", "org_strongminds", "org_taimaka", "org_vitamin_angels" ], "org_count": 19 }, { "id": "income", "name": "Income / cash & poverty effects", "cause_ids": [ "cause_cash_transfers", "cause_deworming" ], "preferred_evaluators": [ "GiveWell", "Happier Lives Institute" ], "matching_metrics": [ "multiple_of_cash" ], "org_ids": [ "org_evidence_action", "org_evidence_action_deworm", "org_fortify_health", "org_givedirectly", "org_sightsavers", "org_unlimit_health" ], "org_count": 6 } ], "families": [ { "outcome": "income", "count": 5, "top_id": "org_givedirectly", "top_name": "GiveDirectly", "methodology_version": "2.0.0" }, { "outcome": "lives_saved", "count": 20, "top_id": "org_helen_keller_intl", "top_name": "Helen Keller Intl", "methodology_version": "2.0.0" }, { "outcome": "wellbeing_wellbys", "count": 19, "top_id": "org_strongminds", "top_name": "StrongMinds", "methodology_version": "2.0.0" } ], "leaderboards": { "lives_saved": { "outcome": "lives_saved", "methodology_version": "2.0.0", "ranked": [ { "rank": 1, "id": "org_helen_keller_intl", "name": "Helen Keller Intl", "recommendation_tier": "top_charity", "conviction_score": 249, "score_components": { "tier": 100, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 20, "confidence": 20, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=top_charity (+100)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_global_health_life_saving, cause_nutrition (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches lives_saved (+40)", "2 verified numeric claim(s) citing eval_gw_hki (+20)", "confidence.overall=high (+20)", "preferred evaluator for lives_saved (+15)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_gw_hki" ], "verified_claims": [ { "evaluation_id": "eval_gw_hki", "label": "Cost per life saved", "value": 3500, "unit": "USD_per_life_saved", "period": "2022-2024 average" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_gw_hki", "label": "Cost per child-year of VAS", "value": 2, "unit": "USD_per_child_year", "period": "2022-2024 average" } ], "citations": [ "https://www.givewell.org/charities/top-charities", "https://helenkellerintl.org/financial-accountability/" ], "caveats": [ "trust flag: EIN_FROM_ORG_PAGE", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 2, "id": "org_malaria_consortium", "name": "Malaria Consortium", "recommendation_tier": "top_charity", "conviction_score": 249, "score_components": { "tier": 100, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 20, "confidence": 20, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=top_charity (+100)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_global_health_life_saving, cause_malaria (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches lives_saved (+40)", "2 verified numeric claim(s) citing eval_gw_mc_smc (+20)", "confidence.overall=high (+20)", "preferred evaluator for lives_saved (+15)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_gw_mc_smc" ], "verified_claims": [ { "evaluation_id": "eval_gw_mc_smc", "label": "Cost per life saved", "value": 4000, "unit": "USD_per_life_saved", "period": "2022-2024 average" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_gw_mc_smc", "label": "Cost per child full SMC course", "value": 7, "unit": "USD_per_child_course", "period": "2022-2024 average" } ], "citations": [ "https://www.givewell.org/charities/top-charities", "https://www.givewell.org/impact-estimates", "https://www.malariaconsortium.org/pages/us/how-to-donate.htm" ], "caveats": [ "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING", "trust flag: EIN_FROM_ORG_PAGE" ] }, { "rank": 3, "id": "org_new_incentives", "name": "New Incentives", "recommendation_tier": "top_charity", "conviction_score": 249, "score_components": { "tier": 100, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 20, "confidence": 20, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=top_charity (+100)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_global_health_life_saving, cause_immunization (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches lives_saved (+40)", "2 verified numeric claim(s) citing eval_gw_ni (+20)", "confidence.overall=high (+20)", "preferred evaluator for lives_saved (+15)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_gw_ni" ], "verified_claims": [ { "evaluation_id": "eval_gw_ni", "label": "Cost per life saved", "value": 4500, "unit": "USD_per_life_saved", "period": "2022-2024 average" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_gw_ni", "label": "Cost per additional infant vaccinated", "value": 146, "unit": "USD_per_infant_vaccinated", "period": "2022-2024 average" } ], "citations": [ "https://www.givewell.org/charities/top-charities", "https://www.every.org/newincentives" ], "caveats": [ "trust flag: EIN_FROM_SECONDARY", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 4, "id": "org_against_malaria_foundation", "name": "Against Malaria Foundation", "recommendation_tier": "top_charity", "conviction_score": 249, "score_components": { "tier": 100, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 20, "confidence": 20, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=top_charity (+100)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_global_health_life_saving, cause_malaria (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches lives_saved (+40)", "2 verified numeric claim(s) citing eval_gw_amf (+20)", "confidence.overall=high (+20)", "preferred evaluator for lives_saved (+15)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_gw_amf" ], "verified_claims": [ { "evaluation_id": "eval_gw_amf", "label": "Cost per life saved", "value": 5500, "unit": "USD_per_life_saved", "period": "2022-2024 average" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_gw_amf", "label": "Cost per net", "value": 6, "unit": "USD_per_net", "period": "2022-2024 average" } ], "citations": [ "https://www.givewell.org/charities/top-charities", "https://www.againstmalaria.com/CharityStatus.aspx?Country=USA" ], "caveats": [ "trust flag: EIN_FROM_ORG_PAGE", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 5, "id": "org_givewell_all_grants_fund", "name": "GiveWell All Grants Fund", "recommendation_tier": "fund", "conviction_score": 180, "score_components": { "tier": 85, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 20, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 10, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=fund (+85)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_global_health_life_saving, cause_nutrition, cause_safe_water (+50)", "confidence.overall=high (+20)", "preferred evaluator for lives_saved (+15)", "irs:exempt_claimed(+4)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_gw_agf" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.givewell.org/our-giving-funds" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 6, "id": "org_givewell_top_charities_fund", "name": "GiveWell Top Charities Fund", "recommendation_tier": "fund", "conviction_score": 178, "score_components": { "tier": 85, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 20, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 8, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=fund (+85)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_global_health_life_saving (+50)", "confidence.overall=high (+20)", "preferred evaluator for lives_saved (+15)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)", "irs:exempt_claimed(+4)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_gw_tcf" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.givewell.org/top-charities-fund" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 7, "id": "org_givewell", "name": "GiveWell", "recommendation_tier": "fund", "conviction_score": 164, "score_components": { "tier": 85, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 10, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=fund (+85)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_global_health_life_saving (+50)", "confidence.overall=medium (+10)", "preferred evaluator for lives_saved (+15)", "irs:exempt_claimed(+4)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_givewell" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.givewell.org/" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 8, "id": "org_givewell_unrestricted_fund", "name": "GiveWell Unrestricted Fund", "recommendation_tier": "fund", "conviction_score": 164, "score_components": { "tier": 85, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 10, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=fund (+85)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_global_health_life_saving (+50)", "confidence.overall=medium (+10)", "preferred evaluator for lives_saved (+15)", "irs:exempt_claimed(+4)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_gw_urf" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.givewell.org/our-giving-funds" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 9, "id": "org_gwwc", "name": "Giving What We Can (reference)", "recommendation_tier": "fund", "conviction_score": 142, "score_components": { "tier": 85, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 10, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": -3, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=fund (+85)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_global_health_life_saving (+50)", "confidence.overall=medium (+10)", "irs:non_us(-3)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_gwwc" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.givingwhatwecan.org/" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 10, "id": "org_ansh", "name": "Ansh", "recommendation_tier": "grant_recipient", "conviction_score": 140, "score_components": { "tier": 30, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 0, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=grant_recipient (+30)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_global_health_life_saving (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches lives_saved (+40)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "preferred evaluator for lives_saved (+15)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_ansh" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://files.givewell.org/files/metrics/GiveWell_Metrics_Report_2024.pdf" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 11, "id": "org_dimagi", "name": "Dimagi", "recommendation_tier": "grant_recipient", "conviction_score": 140, "score_components": { "tier": 30, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 0, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=grant_recipient (+30)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_global_health_life_saving (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches lives_saved (+40)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "preferred evaluator for lives_saved (+15)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_dimagi" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://files.givewell.org/files/metrics/GiveWell_Metrics_Report_2024.pdf" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 12, "id": "org_ea_funds_gh", "name": "EA Funds \u2014 Global Health and Development", "recommendation_tier": "fund", "conviction_score": 140, "score_components": { "tier": 85, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": 0, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=fund (+85)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_global_health_life_saving (+50)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_ea_funds_gh" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://funds.effectivealtruism.org/" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 13, "id": "org_uduma", "name": "Uduma", "recommendation_tier": "grant_recipient", "conviction_score": 140, "score_components": { "tier": 30, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 0, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=grant_recipient (+30)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_safe_water (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches lives_saved (+40)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "preferred evaluator for lives_saved (+15)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_uduma" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://files.givewell.org/files/metrics/GiveWell_Metrics_Report_2024.pdf" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 14, "id": "org_alima", "name": "ALIMA", "recommendation_tier": "grant_recipient", "conviction_score": 137, "score_components": { "tier": 30, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": -3, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=grant_recipient (+30)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_nutrition (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches lives_saved (+40)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "preferred evaluator for lives_saved (+15)", "irs:non_us(-3)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_alima" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://files.givewell.org/files/metrics/GiveWell_Metrics_Report_2024.pdf" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 15, "id": "org_founders_pledge_gh", "name": "Founders Pledge Global Health (reference)", "recommendation_tier": "fund", "conviction_score": 137, "score_components": { "tier": 85, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": -3, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=fund (+85)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_global_health_life_saving (+50)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "irs:non_us(-3)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_founders_pledge_gh" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.founderspledge.com/" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 16, "id": "org_nutrition_international", "name": "Nutrition International", "recommendation_tier": "grant_recipient", "conviction_score": 137, "score_components": { "tier": 30, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": -3, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=grant_recipient (+30)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_nutrition (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches lives_saved (+40)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "preferred evaluator for lives_saved (+15)", "irs:non_us(-3)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_nutrition_international" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://files.givewell.org/files/metrics/GiveWell_Metrics_Report_2024.pdf" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 17, "id": "org_taimaka", "name": "Taimaka", "recommendation_tier": "promising", "conviction_score": 134, "score_components": { "tier": 70, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 10, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=promising (+70)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_nutrition (+50)", "confidence.overall=medium (+10)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_hli_taimaka" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.happierlivesinstitute.org/charities/", "https://taimaka.org/who-we-are" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data", "trust flag: EIN_FROM_ORG_PAGE", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 18, "id": "org_gates_malaria", "name": "Gates Foundation malaria (reference funder)", "recommendation_tier": "fund", "conviction_score": 120, "score_components": { "tier": 85, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": -20, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=fund (+85)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_malaria (+50)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "trust_flag:REFERENCE_OR_RUNNER_UP(-20)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_gates_malaria" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.gatesfoundation.org/" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data", "Labeled runner-up/reference \u2014 not a default Top Charity recommendation" ] }, { "rank": 19, "id": "org_global_fund_malaria", "name": "The Global Fund (malaria portfolio reference)", "recommendation_tier": "fund", "conviction_score": 117, "score_components": { "tier": 85, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": -23, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=fund (+85)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_malaria (+50)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "trust_flag:REFERENCE_OR_RUNNER_UP(-20)", "irs:non_us(-3)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_global_fund_malaria" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.theglobalfund.org/" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data", "Labeled runner-up/reference \u2014 not a default Top Charity recommendation" ] }, { "rank": 20, "id": "org_amf_drc_2027", "name": "AMF \u2014 ITN campaigns DRC 2027\u20132029 (GiveWell grant)", "recommendation_tier": "grant_recipient", "conviction_score": 113, "score_components": { "tier": 30, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 20, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": -2, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=grant_recipient (+30)", "cause overlap for lives_saved: cause_malaria (+50)", "confidence.overall=high (+20)", "preferred evaluator for lives_saved (+15)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_amf_drc_2027" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.givewell.org/research/grants/Against-Malaria-Foundation-ITN-Campaigns-in-DRC-in-2027-2029-May-2026" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] } ] }, "wellbeing_wellbys": { "outcome": "wellbeing_wellbys", "methodology_version": "2.0.0", "ranked": [ { "rank": 1, "id": "org_strongminds", "name": "StrongMinds", "recommendation_tier": "top_charity", "conviction_score": 259, "score_components": { "tier": 100, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 30, "confidence": 20, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=top_charity (+100)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_global_health_wellbeing, cause_mental_health_lmic (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches wellbeing_wellbys (+40)", "5 verified numeric claim(s) citing eval_hli_sm (+30)", "confidence.overall=high (+20)", "preferred evaluator for wellbeing_wellbys (+15)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_hli_sm" ], "verified_claims": [ { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_sm", "label": "WELLBYs per $1,000", "value": 40.37, "unit": "WELLBY_per_1000_USD", "period": "HLI table" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_sm", "label": "Cost per WELLBY", "value": 24.77, "unit": "USD_per_WELLBY", "period": "HLI table" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_sm", "label": "Cost per person treated", "value": 44.56, "unit": "USD_per_person", "period": "HLI table" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_sm", "label": "Effect per person", "value": 1.8, "unit": "WELLBY_per_person", "period": "HLI table" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_sm", "label": "Multiple of GiveDirectly", "value": 5.3, "unit": "x_givedirectly", "period": "HLI comparison" } ], "citations": [ "https://www.happierlivesinstitute.org/charities/", "https://strongminds.org/strongminds-faqs/" ], "caveats": [ "trust flag: EIN_FROM_ORG_PAGE", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 2, "id": "org_friendship_bench", "name": "Friendship Bench", "recommendation_tier": "top_charity", "conviction_score": 258, "score_components": { "tier": 100, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 30, "confidence": 20, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 3, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=top_charity (+100)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_global_health_wellbeing, cause_mental_health_lmic (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches wellbeing_wellbys (+40)", "5 verified numeric claim(s) citing eval_hli_fb (+30)", "confidence.overall=high (+20)", "preferred evaluator for wellbeing_wellbys (+15)", "irs:non_us(-3)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_hli_fb" ], "verified_claims": [ { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_fb", "label": "WELLBYs per $1,000", "value": 48.52, "unit": "WELLBY_per_1000_USD", "period": "HLI table" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_fb", "label": "Cost per WELLBY", "value": 20.61, "unit": "USD_per_WELLBY", "period": "HLI table" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_fb", "label": "Cost per person treated", "value": 16.5, "unit": "USD_per_person", "period": "HLI table" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_fb", "label": "Effect per person", "value": 0.8, "unit": "WELLBY_per_person", "period": "HLI table" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_fb", "label": "Multiple of GiveDirectly", "value": 6.4, "unit": "x_givedirectly", "period": "HLI comparison" } ], "citations": [ "https://www.happierlivesinstitute.org/charities/" ], "caveats": [] }, { "rank": 3, "id": "org_pure_earth", "name": "Pure Earth", "recommendation_tier": "promising", "conviction_score": 219, "score_components": { "tier": 70, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 30, "confidence": 10, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=promising (+70)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_global_health_wellbeing, cause_lead_pollution (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches wellbeing_wellbys (+40)", "3 verified numeric claim(s) citing eval_hli_pe (+30)", "confidence.overall=medium (+10)", "preferred evaluator for wellbeing_wellbys (+15)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_hli_pe" ], "verified_claims": [ { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_pe", "label": "WELLBYs per $1,000", "value": 105.43, "unit": "WELLBY_per_1000_USD", "period": "HLI table" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_pe", "label": "Cost per WELLBY", "value": 9.49, "unit": "USD_per_WELLBY", "period": "HLI table" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_pe", "label": "Multiple of GiveDirectly", "value": 14.0, "unit": "x_givedirectly", "period": "HLI comparison" } ], "citations": [ "https://www.happierlivesinstitute.org/charities/", "https://www.guidestar.org/profile/13-4075779" ], "caveats": [ "trust flag: EIN_FROM_SECONDARY", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 4, "id": "org_taimaka", "name": "Taimaka", "recommendation_tier": "promising", "conviction_score": 219, "score_components": { "tier": 70, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 30, "confidence": 10, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=promising (+70)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_global_health_wellbeing, cause_nutrition (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches wellbeing_wellbys (+40)", "5 verified numeric claim(s) citing eval_hli_taimaka (+30)", "confidence.overall=medium (+10)", "preferred evaluator for wellbeing_wellbys (+15)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_hli_taimaka" ], "verified_claims": [ { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_taimaka", "label": "WELLBYs per $1,000", "value": 66.0, "unit": "WELLBY_per_1000_USD", "period": "HLI table" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_taimaka", "label": "Cost per WELLBY", "value": 15.15, "unit": "USD_per_WELLBY", "period": "HLI table" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_taimaka", "label": "Cost per child treated", "value": 87.21, "unit": "USD_per_child", "period": "HLI table" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_taimaka", "label": "Effect per person", "value": 5.72, "unit": "WELLBY_per_person", "period": "HLI table" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_taimaka", "label": "Multiple of GiveDirectly", "value": 8.7, "unit": "x_givedirectly", "period": "HLI comparison" } ], "citations": [ "https://www.happierlivesinstitute.org/charities/", "https://taimaka.org/who-we-are" ], "caveats": [ "trust flag: EIN_FROM_ORG_PAGE", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 5, "id": "org_givedirectly", "name": "GiveDirectly", "recommendation_tier": "benchmark", "conviction_score": 184, "score_components": { "tier": 45, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 20, "confidence": 10, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=benchmark (+45)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_cash_transfers (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches wellbeing_wellbys (+40)", "2 verified numeric claim(s) citing eval_hli_gd (+20)", "confidence.overall=medium (+10)", "preferred evaluator for wellbeing_wellbys (+15)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_hli_gd" ], "verified_claims": [ { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_gd", "label": "WELLBYs per $1,000 (benchmark)", "value": 7.55, "unit": "WELLBY_per_1000_USD", "period": "HLI FAQ narrative" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_gd", "label": "Multiple of itself", "value": 1.0, "unit": "x_givedirectly", "period": "HLI table" } ], "citations": [ "https://www.happierlivesinstitute.org/charities/", "https://www.charitynavigator.org/ein/271661997" ], "caveats": [ "trust flag: EIN_FROM_SECONDARY", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 6, "id": "org_happier_lives_fund", "name": "Happier Lives Fund", "recommendation_tier": "fund", "conviction_score": 176, "score_components": { "tier": 85, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 20, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 6, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=fund (+85)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_global_health_wellbeing (+50)", "confidence.overall=high (+20)", "preferred evaluator for wellbeing_wellbys (+15)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_hli_fund" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.happierlivesinstitute.org/charities/" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 7, "id": "org_helen_keller_intl", "name": "Helen Keller Intl", "recommendation_tier": "top_charity", "conviction_score": 174, "score_components": { "tier": 100, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 20, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=top_charity (+100)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_nutrition (+50)", "confidence.overall=high (+20)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_gw_hki" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.givewell.org/charities/top-charities", "https://helenkellerintl.org/financial-accountability/" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data", "trust flag: EIN_FROM_ORG_PAGE", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 8, "id": "org_givewell_all_grants_fund", "name": "GiveWell All Grants Fund", "recommendation_tier": "fund", "conviction_score": 165, "score_components": { "tier": 85, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 20, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": 10, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=fund (+85)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_nutrition (+50)", "confidence.overall=high (+20)", "irs:exempt_claimed(+4)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_gw_agf" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.givewell.org/our-giving-funds" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 9, "id": "org_hli", "name": "Happier Lives Institute", "recommendation_tier": "fund", "conviction_score": 157, "score_components": { "tier": 85, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 10, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": -3, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=fund (+85)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_global_health_wellbeing (+50)", "confidence.overall=medium (+10)", "preferred evaluator for wellbeing_wellbys (+15)", "irs:non_us(-3)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_hli" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.happierlivesinstitute.org/" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 10, "id": "org_actra", "name": "ACTRA", "recommendation_tier": "honourable_mention", "conviction_score": 145, "score_components": { "tier": 15, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 20, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 0, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=honourable_mention (+15)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_mental_health_lmic (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches wellbeing_wellbys (+40)", "2 verified numeric claim(s) citing eval_org_actra (+20)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "preferred evaluator for wellbeing_wellbys (+15)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_actra" ], "verified_claims": [ { "evaluation_id": "eval_org_actra", "label": "WELLBYs per $1,000", "value": 37.0, "unit": "WELLBY_per_1000_USD", "period": "HLI honourable" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_org_actra", "label": "Cost per WELLBY", "value": 27.0, "unit": "USD_per_WELLBY", "period": "HLI honourable" } ], "citations": [ "https://www.happierlivesinstitute.org/charities/" ], "caveats": [] }, { "rank": 11, "id": "org_shamiri", "name": "Shamiri Institute", "recommendation_tier": "honourable_mention", "conviction_score": 142, "score_components": { "tier": 15, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 20, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": -3, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=honourable_mention (+15)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_mental_health_lmic (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches wellbeing_wellbys (+40)", "2 verified numeric claim(s) citing eval_org_shamiri (+20)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "preferred evaluator for wellbeing_wellbys (+15)", "irs:non_us(-3)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_shamiri" ], "verified_claims": [ { "evaluation_id": "eval_org_shamiri", "label": "WELLBYs per $1,000", "value": 32.93, "unit": "WELLBY_per_1000_USD", "period": "HLI honourable" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_org_shamiri", "label": "Cost per WELLBY", "value": 30.37, "unit": "USD_per_WELLBY", "period": "HLI honourable" } ], "citations": [ "https://www.happierlivesinstitute.org/charities/" ], "caveats": [] }, { "rank": 12, "id": "org_gwwc", "name": "Giving What We Can (reference)", "recommendation_tier": "fund", "conviction_score": 142, "score_components": { "tier": 85, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 10, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": -3, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=fund (+85)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_global_health_wellbeing (+50)", "confidence.overall=medium (+10)", "irs:non_us(-3)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_gwwc" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.givingwhatwecan.org/" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 13, "id": "org_fortify_health", "name": "Fortify Health", "recommendation_tier": "grant_recipient", "conviction_score": 137, "score_components": { "tier": 30, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 40, "verified_claims": 10, "confidence": 10, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": -3, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=grant_recipient (+30)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_nutrition (+50)", "evaluation outcome_metric matches wellbeing_wellbys (+40)", "1 verified numeric claim(s) citing eval_org_fortify_health (+10)", "confidence.overall=medium (+10)", "irs:non_us(-3)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_fortify_health" ], "verified_claims": [ { "evaluation_id": "eval_org_fortify_health", "label": "Multiple of GiveDirectly", "value": 2.9, "unit": "x_givedirectly", "period": "HLI comparison table" } ], "citations": [ "https://www.happierlivesinstitute.org/charities/", "https://www.givewell.org/research/incubation-grants/Fortify-Health-expansion-December-2021" ], "caveats": [] }, { "rank": 14, "id": "org_evidence_action", "name": "Evidence Action", "recommendation_tier": "grant_recipient", "conviction_score": 94, "score_components": { "tier": 30, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 10, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=grant_recipient (+30)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_nutrition (+50)", "confidence.overall=medium (+10)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_gw_ea" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.charitynavigator.org/ein/900874591" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data", "trust flag: EIN_FROM_SECONDARY", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 15, "id": "org_evidence_action_ifa", "name": "Equal Vitamin Access / IFA TA India (Evidence Action)", "recommendation_tier": "grant_recipient", "conviction_score": 83, "score_components": { "tier": 30, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": -2, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=grant_recipient (+30)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_nutrition (+50)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_evidence_action_ifa" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.givewell.org/research/grants/evidence-action-iron-folic-acid-supplementation-india-august-2022" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 16, "id": "org_alima", "name": "ALIMA", "recommendation_tier": "grant_recipient", "conviction_score": 82, "score_components": { "tier": 30, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": -3, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=grant_recipient (+30)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_nutrition (+50)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "irs:non_us(-3)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_alima" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://files.givewell.org/files/metrics/GiveWell_Metrics_Report_2024.pdf" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 17, "id": "org_nutrition_international", "name": "Nutrition International", "recommendation_tier": "grant_recipient", "conviction_score": 82, "score_components": { "tier": 30, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": -3, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=grant_recipient (+30)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_nutrition (+50)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "irs:non_us(-3)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_nutrition_international" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://files.givewell.org/files/metrics/GiveWell_Metrics_Report_2024.pdf" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 18, "id": "org_iodine_global_network", "name": "Iodine Global Network", "recommendation_tier": "runner_up", "conviction_score": 40, "score_components": { "tier": 5, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": -20, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=runner_up (+5)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_nutrition (+50)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "trust_flag:REFERENCE_OR_RUNNER_UP(-20)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_iodine_global_network" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://ign.org/" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data", "Labeled runner-up/reference \u2014 not a default Top Charity recommendation" ] }, { "rank": 19, "id": "org_vitamin_angels", "name": "Vitamin Angels", "recommendation_tier": "runner_up", "conviction_score": 40, "score_components": { "tier": 5, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 0, "trust": -20, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=runner_up (+5)", "cause overlap for wellbeing_wellbys: cause_nutrition (+50)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "trust_flag:REFERENCE_OR_RUNNER_UP(-20)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_vitamin_angels" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://vitaminangels.org/" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data", "Labeled runner-up/reference \u2014 not a default Top Charity recommendation" ] } ] }, "income": { "outcome": "income", "methodology_version": "2.0.0", "ranked": [ { "rank": 1, "id": "org_givedirectly", "name": "GiveDirectly", "recommendation_tier": "benchmark", "conviction_score": 144, "score_components": { "tier": 45, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 20, "confidence": 10, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=benchmark (+45)", "cause overlap for income: cause_cash_transfers (+50)", "2 verified numeric claim(s) citing eval_hli_gd (+20)", "confidence.overall=medium (+10)", "preferred evaluator for income (+15)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_hli_gd" ], "verified_claims": [ { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_gd", "label": "WELLBYs per $1,000 (benchmark)", "value": 7.55, "unit": "WELLBY_per_1000_USD", "period": "HLI FAQ narrative" }, { "evaluation_id": "eval_hli_gd", "label": "Multiple of itself", "value": 1.0, "unit": "x_givedirectly", "period": "HLI table" } ], "citations": [ "https://www.happierlivesinstitute.org/charities/", "https://www.charitynavigator.org/ein/271661997" ], "caveats": [ "trust flag: EIN_FROM_SECONDARY", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 2, "id": "org_evidence_action", "name": "Evidence Action", "recommendation_tier": "grant_recipient", "conviction_score": 109, "score_components": { "tier": 30, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 10, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": 4, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=grant_recipient (+30)", "cause overlap for income: cause_deworming (+50)", "confidence.overall=medium (+10)", "preferred evaluator for income (+15)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_gw_ea" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.charitynavigator.org/ein/900874591" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data", "trust flag: EIN_FROM_SECONDARY", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 3, "id": "org_evidence_action_deworm", "name": "Deworm the World (Evidence Action)", "recommendation_tier": "former_top", "conviction_score": 93, "score_components": { "tier": 25, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": -2, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=former_top (+25)", "cause overlap for income: cause_deworming (+50)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "preferred evaluator for income (+15)", "trust_flag:IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING(-2)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_evidence_action_deworm" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://www.evidenceaction.org/programs/deworm-the-world" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data", "trust flag: IRS_TEOS_LOOKUP_PENDING" ] }, { "rank": 4, "id": "org_sightsavers", "name": "Sightsavers", "recommendation_tier": "former_top", "conviction_score": 92, "score_components": { "tier": 25, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": -3, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=former_top (+25)", "cause overlap for income: cause_deworming (+50)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "preferred evaluator for income (+15)", "irs:non_us(-3)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_sightsavers" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://files.givewell.org/files/metrics/GiveWell_Metrics_Report_2024.pdf" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] }, { "rank": 5, "id": "org_unlimit_health", "name": "Unlimit Health (formerly SCI Foundation)", "recommendation_tier": "former_top", "conviction_score": 92, "score_components": { "tier": 25, "outcome_fit": 50, "metric_fit": 0, "verified_claims": 0, "confidence": 5, "evaluator_alignment": 15, "trust": -3, "profile": 0 }, "rationale": [ "recommendation_tier=former_top (+25)", "cause overlap for income: cause_deworming (+50)", "confidence.overall=low (+5)", "preferred evaluator for income (+15)", "irs:non_us(-3)" ], "evaluation_ids": [ "eval_org_unlimit_health" ], "verified_claims": [], "citations": [ "https://files.givewell.org/files/metrics/GiveWell_Metrics_Report_2024.pdf" ], "caveats": [ "No verified numeric CE claims for this outcome in our data" ] } ] } }, "recommend_endpoint": "/v1/recommend?outcome=", "outcomes_endpoint": "/v1/outcomes", "mixes_units_in_ranking": false, "moral_weights_status": "proposed", "adr": "docs/adr/0007-cross-cause-moral-weights.md", "methodology_moral_weights": "docs/methodology-moral-weights.md", "recommended_default": "separate_leaderboards_per_outcome_family", "disclaimer": "Better World keeps separate leaderboards per outcome family and does not mix WELLBYs with lives_saved (or other units) into one ranked list. Converting across units is a human moral-weight choice we do not invent. See docs/adr/0007-cross-cause-moral-weights.md (Proposed; mixes_units_in_ranking: false) and docs/methodology-moral-weights.md.", "provenance": { "product_version": "0.2.16", "data_snapshot_id": "4d4f52c9ad30", "generated_at_iso": "2026-10-24T15:30:58Z", "mixes_units_in_ranking": false } }